Monday, July 12, 2010

Re: Roy

Roy's blog post on Lady Gaga appeared to be an outline. I feel like It was unclear exactly what point he was trying to get across. The best way I could advise him to improve his post would be to choose a specific topic about Lady Gaga and fully flesh it out.
It seems that Roy is primarily focusing on Gaga's aesthetic and performances. I would look further into the influences that contribute to the pop star's persona (Madonna, David Bowie, etc.). How do the artists that influence Gaga differ from the style that she is creating? Roy lists musical icons that have influenced Gaga's fashion, but neglects the obvious influence of high-fashion and couture. Gaga often times wears garments that are right off the runway (She is famous for her friendship with the former Alexander McQueen, Zac Posen, Christian Dior, etc.) Roy should be able to find many interviews with Lady Gaga focus on her fashion choices, and she speaks openly about being seen as an outsider/ freak. How can Roy tie in what the artist herself expresses to the observations he is making?
There has also been a lot of controversy pertaining to the similarities between lady Gaga and Roisin Murphy (an electro pop artist primarily popular in the UK)- how have musical genres other than mainstream pop have influenced the persona Gaga is trying to create? How do her radical performances contrast her mediocre pop music? Why is she seen as one of the most original pop stars of the 21st century?
I think that going more in depth with the comparisons will be essential to get the point you want to make across. I personally feel that the background info, which is the bulk of the text, is irrelevant to the topic Roy is exploring.

Here is a link to an interesting comparison between Gaga and Murphy:

No comments:

Post a Comment